identity / asian-american-politics-and-representation · article
identity/ · 2,267 w · 10 min · ✎ dialogue

Asian American Politics and Representation

Asian Americans are the fastest-growing racial group in the U.S. — yet they are among the least politically organized, least represented in elected office, and least visible in mainstream media. The structural challenges are real: a fragmented electorate spread across dozens of national-origin communities, deep skepticism of political participation among first-generation immigrants, and a persistent "perpetual foreigner" stigma that questions their legitimacy as candidates and leaders. Andrew Yang's 2020 presidential campaign served as a stress test for all of these dynamics simultaneously, while 88Rising and #StarringJohnCho represent the parallel project of building cultural infrastructure that mainstream institutions refuse to provide. Together, these cases reveal the dual challenge Asian Americans face: winning recognition within systems that weren't built for them, while building alternative systems when those fail.

Political Underrepresentation: The Numbers

  • Asian Americans constitute 5-6% of the national population but held only 2.4% of seats in the 113th Congress
  • Fewer than 2% of state legislators are Asian American
  • Asian Americans are the least likely of any ethnic group to vote, donate, or run for office
  • At the same time, the fastest-growing racial group is becoming an increasingly decisive bloc in swing states — a political power that is both real and consistently underutilized

The explanations are structural, not cultural:

First-generation immigration skepticism: East Asian immigrants, particularly from mainland China, often carry deep skepticism of political participation rooted in experience with authoritarian government. As one former Chinese finance ministry official told The Economist: "We went through the Cultural Revolution. There's a lack of trust in politics." You don't volunteer for civic institutions when civic institutions have historically destroyed your family.

Citizenship gaps: Many Asian Americans are non-citizens who cannot vote. Jason's father Anping Shen, running for Newton's school committee in 2017, noted: "I would often say during the campaign that 20% of Newton's population was Asian American, but what I didn't say was that less than half of Asian families were citizens, and therefore could vote." The community appears larger than its electoral footprint.

South Asian contrast: South Asian Americans are more politically prepared — India is the world's largest democracy, and political participation is normalized across generations. This partly explains the disproportionate visibility of Indian-origin politicians (Nikki Haley, Bobby Jindal, Kamala Harris) relative to East Asian-origin politicians.

The pipeline problem: When Grace Meng decided to run for Congress in 2012, she called every Asian American elected official she could find to take the temperature. The calls took five minutes. The pool was that small.

The Perpetual Foreigner in Politics

Asian American candidates face a specific form of the perpetual foreigner dynamic: their Americanness is questioned in ways that white candidates and even Black and Hispanic candidates rarely encounter. The mechanism is explicit questioning of loyalty and belonging, not just implicit bias.

Andy Kim (D-NJ): Kim ran in New Jersey's 3rd district, which is 85% white and had voted for Trump by 6 points. Attack ads deployed the explicit line: "He's not one of us." Kim later said: "I can't help but feel certain things when I hear those words — I've heard them before in my life." He won anyway, becoming the first Korean American Democrat elected to Congress, by framing his parents' immigrant story as a fundamentally American one rather than a Korean one. He didn't hide his identity; he translated it.

Kim's experience at the State Department further illustrates the dynamic. Despite holding the highest level of security clearance available in government and working on Iraq and Afghanistan issues, Kim was not allowed to work on Korea policy without filing a formal appeal. A colleague born in Brazil would not face similar restrictions on Brazilian issues. The perpetual foreigner stigma had institutional force, not just social.

Tammy Duckworth: During a televised Senate debate, Duckworth highlighted her family's multi-generational military service. Her opponent, Sen. Mark Kirk, responded: "I had forgotten that your parents came all the way from Thailand to serve George Washington." Duckworth had lost both legs in combat. Kirk was still denying her American heritage.

MSNBC, 1998 Olympics: The network's headline "American beats Kwan" — implying that figure skater Michelle Kwan, competing for the United States, was not American.

The CNN question: When Yang appeared on CNN to discuss the Freedom Dividend, anchor Chris Cuomo's opening question was whether giving citizens money was "American" as a solution. Elizabeth Warren's proposal to eliminate $640B in student debt and Bernie Sanders's explicit democratic socialism were not framed through the "Is this American?" lens. The question was asked of the Asian candidate.

Andrew Yang's Campaign: A Case Study

The Identity Strategy

Yang's signature political frame — "The opposite of Donald Trump is an Asian man who likes math" — was calibrated to activate the "competent" half of the warmth/competence stereotype while simultaneously deflecting the "cold" half through humor and self-awareness. In a private address to a Chinese American audience, he was more direct: he told them he ran because Asian Americans could be "this successful" (hand to shoulder) "but not this successful" (hand above head). The ceiling was the subject.

Yang's campaign was genuinely unconventional in the warmth dimension. He crowd-surfed at rallies, dropped F-bombs, wrote clever New Yorker cartoon captions, cried several times on camera while discussing his sons (one of whom has autism), and built a coalition of 400,000 donors including independents and disaffected Republicans. Former Obama advisor Ben Rhodes said it would be "insane" for Democrats not to learn from what Yang built. CNN commentator Van Jones called it "positive populism" — not predicated on grievance.

The warmth breakthrough was significant: research consistently finds that Asian Americans are rated high on competence but low on warmth (see asian-american-identity). Yang found ways to perform warmth credibly, not as performance but as authentic exuberance. Senator Cory Booker said getting to know Yang was one of his "most unexpected pleasures." That kind of statement, applied to an Asian American man, was genuinely unusual.

Media Marginalization

The media treatment of Yang was documented obsessively by his supporters under #YangMediaBlackOut:

  • Least speaking time in the first Democratic debate: under 6 minutes, dead last
  • MSNBC published a graphic showing 20 candidates — and omitted Yang entirely
  • He was repeatedly misnamed "John Yang" on chyrons
  • He was called on least by moderators in all six debates he participated in
  • Supporters counted instances of being confused with other Asian people on air

The irony Jason noted: Yang's most positive media surge came from his exit announcement. The coverage that greeted him dropping out was warmer than anything produced during his candidacy. The establishment noticed him when he stopped competing.

The Washington Post Op-Ed and the COVID Backlash

In April 2020, Yang published a Washington Post op-ed arguing that Asian Americans should "embrace and show our Americanness" in response to COVID-related xenophobia — including wearing red, white, and blue. The backlash from prominent Asian Americans was immediate and harsh:

Jeff Yang wrote: "This is not it, Andrew. It shouldn't be on Asians to prove we're American by sacrifice. That hasn't protected us before and won't now. We prove we're American by fighting things that should be un-American, like racism — and not just when it happens to us."

Eddie Huang, Simu Liu, and Steven Yeun joined the criticism. The op-ed read as instructing Asian Americans to perform loyalty on demand — an echo of internment-era logic that Japanese American loyalty had to be demonstrated through sacrifice rather than assumed as default.

Yang acknowledged the piece "fell short." The episode reveals a genuine strategic disagreement within the community: whether to engage in bridge-building (Yang's inclination) or aggressive public advocacy (his critics' demand). Jason's analysis: social change requires both. "You need people on one side calling out prejudice and hate and making aggressive demands for change. You need others on the side offering acceptable solutions that bring people together." The problem was that Yang positioned himself as the only voice, which made his moderation look like capitulation.

The Community Split

Generational and class fault lines ran through Yang's support:

  • Younger Asian Americans were excited about representation for its own sake; older voters, particularly Chinese Americans, were more skeptical about his substance
  • His UBI policy split middle-class Asian professionals (many of whom feared its implications for means-tested programs they relied on)
  • His fundraising from Asian Americans was significant but placed him fifth among Democrats in Q1 2019
  • He was criticized for the "knowing a lot of doctors" quip at the third debate (seen as reinforcing model minority tropes) and for declining to call for Shane Gillis's firing from SNL after Gillis made racist jokes at Yang's expense

The Gillis episode captured the bind. Some argued Yang should have demanded accountability. Others argued that his "Humanity First" approach — extending an invitation to dialogue rather than punishment — was strategically sound for building a broad coalition. The underlying question: does a minority candidate have the luxury of not defending his community publicly, or does bridge-building require absorbing some racism for the sake of the larger goal?

Coalition-Building as Political Necessity

Asian American candidates typically cannot rely on a monolithic ethnic voting bloc. The math doesn't work: even in heavily Asian districts, citizenship gaps and turnout disparities shrink the actual electorate. Beyond that, the 23-plus national-origin communities that constitute "Asian America" do not vote as a bloc.

This forces a different political strategy — universal storytelling over identity politics:

  • Andy Kim won in an 85% white Trump district by framing his Korean immigrant parents' story as a fundamentally American story: son of immigrants who became a PhD in genetics and a nurse, pursuing service in the national interest. He never hid his heritage; he translated its meaning.
  • Grace Meng (D-NY), even in a 40% Asian American district in Queens, told the story of voters who were shocked to hear her speaking English in a robo-call. The perpetual foreigner assumption ran even in diverse communities.
  • Anping Shen (Jason's father), running for Newton's school committee in 2017, won by knocking on more doors than his opponent, mobilizing the Asian American community, and building enough cross-racial support to defeat a Harvard PhD with stronger establishment backing. He outworked the disadvantage.

Gary Locke's line captures the narrative power when it works: he told the story that his grandfather lived near the Washington state governor's mansion, and it took three generations to move 100 feet to occupy that office. It's a version of Obama's "this could only happen in America" — the immigrant story converted into an American story, not a foreign one.

Media Representation: 88Rising and #StarringJohnCho

88Rising

Sean Miyashiro's label built the institutional infrastructure for Asian American cultural visibility that mainstream media refused to provide:

  • Joji: first Asia-born artist to top the Billboard R&B/Hip-Hop chart
  • Rich Brian: first Asian artist to reach #1 on the Hip-Hop iTunes album chart
  • Higher Brothers: rapped almost entirely in Chinese and sold out North American tours
  • Founded the first Asian-centric music festival in America (Head In The Clouds)
  • Strategy: "Rappers React" videos converted hip-hop credibility into mainstream accessibility without erasing Asian identity

The model was not to ask for a seat at mainstream media's table but to build a parallel table. The distribution infrastructure (YouTube, streaming, social media) made this viable in a way it wasn't in earlier decades. Once the platform existed and the audience was demonstrated, mainstream access followed rather than preceded.

#StarringJohnCho

William Yu's 2016 campaign photoshopped John Cho onto blockbuster movie posters to demonstrate visually what an Asian American lead looks like. The selection criteria were deliberate: Cho needed leading-man experience, critical acclaim, box office track record, and cult following (Harold and Kumar, Star Trek). He satisfied all four.

Yu's framing: "I needed something for people to visually look at that they also couldn't refute — it just looked so convincing." The argument was made through demonstration, not argument. The campaign went viral in Germany, Korea, Australia, and Hong Kong — resonating beyond the Asian American community — which confirmed that the argument was not about identity politics but about the simple question of what a lead looks like.

Andrew Kung's Photography

Photographer Andrew Kung left Silicon Valley to create a book centering Asian American male experience. His approach to masculinity: not "beautiful runway models" or conventionally masculine archetypes, but "your average Asian American man — finding beauty in that intimacy and tenderness." One spread showed an Asian American man who is also a drag artist — exploring both ends of the stereotype spectrum simultaneously: Asian men desexualized and treated as weak, Asian women exoticized and fetishized. The drag persona resolved nothing; it made the trap visible.

Kung's key tension, articulated explicitly: growing up in the Bay Area surrounded by other Asians, he had never needed to think critically about his identity. It was only through interviewing friends from other parts of the country that he recognized the micro-aggressions he had experienced but never named. The photography project was an act of naming — giving form to experience that had been present but invisible.

Thread · 0 replies+ add reply
no replies yet — be the first to write back to this article.