frameworks / analogies-and-metaphor · article
frameworks/ · 1,061 w · 5 min · ✎ dialogue

Analogies and Metaphor

Jason treats metaphor as one of his most powerful coaching tools — not as decorative language, but as a serious thinking instrument that helps clients feel understood, unlocks creative problem-solving, and makes abstract ideas stick. He has an entire newsletter dedicated to arguing that analogies are "OP" (overpowered), a gaming term for something so effective it borders on unfair. The piece is explicitly a meta-commentary on his own rhetorical method — which is saturated with metaphor, from gymnastics as the template for conviction to rivers as the model for expertise.

From newsletter #233 "Analogies are OP" (2025-01-11).

The Two Superpowers

Jason identifies two distinct payoffs when analogies land:

1. Helping clients feel understood

When a client says they're struggling and lost, Jason might offer: "It sounds like you're wandering through a dark forest, not sure if you're going in circles."

If he nails it, they light up: "Yes, exactly!" The recognition isn't just agreement — it's the feeling that he's tapped their emotional state without parroting their words. That recognition opens a new surface for exploration. And often, the client extends the metaphor themselves:

"Lately I've been lying down in the forest waiting for dawn, but the sun never comes up."

By running with the metaphor, they're engaging the problem in a new modality. The dark forest isn't the problem — it's a handle for the problem. Once they have the handle, they can turn it in their hands and look at different sides.

2. Creative problem-solving

Analogies stick because they're visual and memorable. When one situation maps to another, new strategies become visible that weren't visible in the abstract frame.

Jason's example: telling a founder "you've set up shop at the busiest intersection in town" immediately clarifies why it's hard to grab attention in a crowded market. The same founder, given the abstract advice "your market is crowded," would nod politely and do nothing. Given the intersection image, they start thinking about moving, about signage, about what a better location would look like.

Turning Complex Into Familiar

The underlying mechanism is cognitive scaffolding: people learn new things more easily when they can build on what they already know. An analogy is a bridge from familiar territory to new understanding.

Some of the biggest ideas in intellectual history spread because of great analogies:

  • Einstein's rubber-sheet model of relativity. Space-time as a stretched fabric warped by heavy objects. You can see the gravity well. The math is accessible because the picture is.
  • Darwin's natural selection via artificial breeding. Farmers shape animal traits through selective breeding; nature does the same thing across millions of years. A concept people already knew became the entry point to a concept they didn't.
  • "Mitochondria are the powerhouse of the cell." A meme, yes — but it survived thirty years of biology textbooks precisely because everyone knows what a powerhouse does.
  • Computing's office metaphors. Files, folders, a magnifying glass for search, a paper plane for sending. The digital world is legible because it borrows the vocabulary of the physical one.

How to Wield Them

Jason offers a practical protocol:

  1. Really understand the concept first. If your own grasp is fuzzy, your analogy will be fuzzier. The analogy isn't a substitute for understanding.
  2. Pick something familiar to your audience. Everyday stuff — relationships, shopping, sports — works broadly. But stronger connections come from topics the audience deeply cares about.
  3. Personalize the domain. With tech founder clients, Jason uses coding metaphors for social dynamics — pair programming, staging environment, shipping to production. If you know your audience's hobbies or favorite shows (and share the fluency), use those.
  4. Focus on 2–3 key parallels, not total mapping. No analogy is perfect. Don't try to make every detail line up. Aim for two or three clear connections and let the rest fall away.
  5. Let the audience extend it. The best sign an analogy landed is when the listener starts building on it themselves. That's when thinking gets unlocked.

Jason's Own Analogy Library

This newsletter is explicitly meta: Jason is teaching the tool he uses constantly. Across his archive, the repeat analogies are worth noting:

Each one of these does the scaffolding work — taking an abstract claim about how to live or work and anchoring it in something visual, physical, or already-understood.

Why This Is Craft, Not Flourish

The piece is quietly a defense of metaphor against accusations of imprecision. Analogies are often treated as dumbing-down — a way to make ideas accessible to people who can't handle the real thing. Jason's position is the opposite: analogies are the real thing. They're how thinking actually happens. The abstract framework behind a good analogy is usually arrived at by the analogy, not before it.

This matters for coaches, founders, and anyone trying to get an idea across. An idea without a handle doesn't move. A handle without a firm grip isn't worth having. Great analogies give you both.

Thread · 0 replies+ add reply
no replies yet — be the first to write back to this article.